Three 9-inch round cake pans in light aluminum, gold nonstick and dark nonstick finishes lined up on a kitchen counter
America’s Test Kitchen, Reviewed, Wirecutter and TechGearLab each crowned a different pan as their top pick. The gaps between those picks come down to coating, color and depth.
The best cake pans for most bakers are light-colored, straight-sided 9-inch rounds at least 2 inches deep. America’s Test Kitchen picked the Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro as its winner, and its Best Buy, the Nordic Ware Naturals Nonstick, costs about half as much. Dark finishes sometimes domed or over-browned cakes in those tests.
Key Takeaways
- The best cake pans for layers are light-colored, straight-sided and at least 2 inches deep.
- The Nordic Ware Naturals Nonstick 9-inch is ATK’s value pick, at about half the winner’s price.
- Test kitchens split on uncoated aluminum such as Fat Daddio’s. If you choose it, line the pan with parchment.
- Reviewed’s springform pick is the Hiware three-pan set at about $22. Cheaper springforms leaked in its tests.
- Nonstick coatings differ in chemistry. If PFAS matters to you, compare coatings and check your state’s cookware rules.
- Hand wash, use silicone or wood tools, and cool cakes 15 to 30 minutes before turning them out.
Best cake pans at a glance: picks by cake type
Pick the pan for the cake you bake most, then add others as your baking widens. The best cake pans below come from five published test-kitchen reviews, and no single reviewer tested every pan here. Where they disagree, the sections after the table say so.
| Pan | Best for | Material and finish | Approx. price | Who picked it |
| Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro 9-inch | Layer cakes | Aluminized steel, light nonstick | Roughly double Nordic Ware | ATK winner |
| Nordic Ware Naturals Nonstick 9-inch | Value layers | Aluminum, light nonstick | About half the winner | ATK Best Buy |
| USA Pan 9-inch round | Durable all-rounder | Aluminized steel, silicone-based coating | $23 | Wirecutter top pick |
| Chicago Metallic Commercial II 9-inch | Budget nonstick | Aluminized steel, nonstick | $14.99 | Reviewed best overall |
| Fat Daddio’s 9 x 2-inch | Bakers who line pans | Anodized aluminum, uncoated | $17 | Saveur favorite (8 x 3 size) |
| Hiware springform set | Cheesecake | Steel, nonstick | $21.99 | Reviewed |
| Nordic Ware Heritage Bundt | Bundt cakes | Heavy nonstick | $40 | Reviewed |
Wirecutter says USA Pan came out on top in its tests of round, rectangular and loaf pans. TechGearLab gave the USA Pan 8-inch round its Best Round Pan award. Treat every price as ballpark.
Best cake pans for layer cakes
ATK wants round pans at least 2 inches deep with straight sides, because angled sides make worse layers. Its 9-inch winner is light-colored aluminized steel that baked tall, level, golden cakes and released everything cleanly. The Nordic Ware Naturals Nonstick finished a hair behind on browning, at about half the price.
The USA Pan shows how far testers disagree. ATK rated it well, with layers a little shorter than the winner’s. Reviewed found it domed the most of its 12 pans. Wirecutter still names it first. Saveur notes the maker advises against cooking spray, so use grease and flour.
Size changes the math. ATK says the same batter fills two 9-inch pans or three 8-inch pans, and the thinner 8-inch layers bake sooner. A third layer also eats about a cup more frosting. Nine-inch layers are thick enough to split into four, which 8-inch layers aren’t. cake pan size conversion chart
Buy three of whichever you choose. Sally’s Baking Addiction recommends baking all the batter at once, and with only two pans the last layer has to wait.
Nonstick or uncoated: where the test kitchens split
Uncoated pans made removal hard in ATK’s tests, and pan pizza fused to them despite greasing. Its uncoated Fat Daddio’s 9 x 2-inch pan released cake fine, with only slightly sloping edges, but the pizza earned it a middle rating. Saveur went the other way. It named an uncoated Fat Daddio’s 8 x 3-inch pan its best non-nonstick and value pick. Reviewed’s 3-inch Fat Daddio’s pan stuck every cake.
Prep is one explanation. Saveur greased traditional pans, lined them with parchment, greased again and floured. Reviewed’s write-up never mentions parchment.
My position: if you bake mostly cakes and line every pan, uncoated anodized aluminum works at about $17 a pan. If you bake sticky things, hate lining or hate scrubbing, buy nonstick. The best cake pans in either camp release cleanly when the prep fits the surface.
Check sidewalls on nonstick pans, too. TechGearLab noted that its Wilton square pans have slightly slanted sides, which don’t suit every cake.
Pan color: why dark pans dome
Dark finishes absorb more heat, so the edges of the batter set before the center finishes rising. The center then pushes up into a dome. ATK saw this in a dark Chicago Metallic pan, whose finish set the edges too fast. Its dark Cuisinart overbrowned cakes into sloped, squat layers, and the dark Calphalon baked some of the darkest, least-risen cakes. Saveur reported faster baking and drier layers from shallow, dark-sided pans.
Two baked cake layers side by side, one golden and level from a light pan and one darker with a domed top from a dark pan
Then there’s the counterexample. Reviewed ranked a Chicago Metallic nonstick pan first, with round cakes and little doming. Different oven, different batter (a cake mix), different result. Dark isn’t a dealbreaker, and $14.99 helps. If you buy dark, start checking the cake a minute or two early. Reviewed also suggests cake strips, which wrap the pan to slow edge baking. For tiered cakes, the best cake pans are light-colored and straight-sided, since doming forces you to trim every top before stacking. Depth, diameter and volume: check these before you buy
Three numbers decide whether a pan fits your recipes.
Depth. ATK wants at least 2 inches. Saveur says traditional layer pans run 1.5 to 2 inches deep. Sally’s warns that 1.5-inch pans can spill over. Three-inch pans like the Fat Daddio’s 8 x 3 give taller layers, but they bake longer, and the maker suggests a slightly lower oven temperature, especially if yours runs hot.
Diameter. Reviewed measured a Parrish pan sold as 9 inches and found it slightly smaller. Even the best cake pans deserve a tape measure.
Volume. Sally’s puts a 9 x 2-inch round at about 8 cups and an 8 x 2-inch round at about 6, matching an 8-inch square pan and a 9 x 5 loaf. Some online charts list 4 and 6 cups for the same rounds. I can’t tell why, so measure yours. Fill the pan with water to the rim, pour it into a measuring jug, and write the number on masking tape under the pan.
Best springform pan for cheesecake
Springforms let you free a cheesecake without flipping it, and they leak more than any other cake pan type. Reviewed said lower-quality models leaked badly. Its pick, the Hiware set of three (4, 7 and 9 inches, about $22), baked without burning, leaking or sticking. The 9- and 7-inch cakes domed slightly, and the dimpled bottoms were hard to grease and clean.

A 9-inch springform pan with the side released, showing a cheesecake with a smooth side and a parchment-lined base
TechGearLab picked the Hiware 6-inch for cheesecake. It ships with pre-cut parchment, though the graham crust still needed a knife to release. TechGearLab lists the coating as free of PFOA, BPA and PTFE.
Skip two-in-one pans. Reviewed’s Ballarini round-and-bundt springform, about $32, stuck all three cakes, scratched, and leaked batter from the base.
For a no-coating option, Saveur says some bakers use Fat Daddio’s 3-inch straight-sided pans for cheesecake, lined with a parchment circle. Whichever you buy, set the pan on a sheet pan before it goes in the oven. A leak then lands on the sheet instead of the oven floor.
Best bundt and angel food cake pans
Bundt pans live or die on release. Reviewed’s pick, the Nordic Ware Heritage at about $40, released cakes easily and gave them shiny edges. The downsides are storage space and deep grooves that take effort to clean. For less, the Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 9.5-inch fluted pan at $16.95 baked evenly and unmolded cleanly. Reviewed warns that its Xylan coating can be dangerous above 500 degrees F, so don’t heat the pan empty. TechGearLab’s bundt pick, the Wilton Perfect Results 9-inch, adds handles and a wide lip that catches overflow.
Angel food and chiffon cakes break the usual rules. ATK says a tube pan is essential for angel food cake. The batter climbs the walls as it rises, so you can’t grease the pan. TechGearLab liked the Wilton 10-inch tube pan for its feet and removable bottom, which let you cool the cake upside down without balancing it on a bottle. The aluminum is thin, and getting the center core out without tearing the top took effort.
Best square and 9×13 cake pans
Square pans follow the same rules as the best cake pans for layers: light color, straight sides, clean corners. Saveur’s top nonstick square is the Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro, 8 x 8 x 2 inches and rated to 450 degrees F. Testers said its corners released without damage. Corners are where square pans usually fail. ATK’s Best Buy 8-inch square, the Wilton Perfect Results Premium Nonstick, shares the winner’s rounded corners and tapered edges. It’s a touch darker and browns faster. Seamless molded pans were also easier to clean than folded pans, which trap crumbs. TechGearLab’s square pick is the OXO Good Grips 9-inch at $23, with a dimpled bottom for release
For sheet cakes, Sally’s says a 9 x 13-inch pan holds about 3 quarts. Wirecutter tested 8 x 8 and 13 x 9 sizes. A lid helps if you carry cake to potlucks, and Nordic Ware’s covered 9 x 13 is uncoated and not dishwasher safe. best baking sheets
Non-toxic cake pans and PFAS: what to check
Many of the best cake pans use nonstick coatings, and the chemistry varies by pan. TechGearLab flags Chicago Metallic’s 3-piece set as PTFE-based, and the OXO square carries a ceramic-reinforced PTFE coating. USA Pan’s patented Americoat is silicone-based, and TechGearLab lists it as free of PFOAs, PTFEs and BPAs. Saveur calls the Goldtouch Pro free of PFOA and PFOS. That’s a narrower claim than PFAS-free, so read it that way.
Ceramic isn’t an automatic fix. Quality and PFAS content vary by brand. Uncoated anodized aluminum sidesteps the question, and Saveur lists Fat Daddio’s at 550 degrees F.
The rules are changing. Minnesota’s cookware ban took effect in 2025, Maine and Colorado followed in January 2026, and Connecticut, Vermont and Washington have bans scheduled. Sources disagree on exact dates, and each law defines “cookware” differently, so check whether yours covers bakeware. [EXTERNAL LINK: Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, PFAS in cookware] The laws restrict sales, not ownership.
For a head-to-head, Mimi’s Organic Eats baked the same vanilla cake in Kana, USA Pan, Caraway and Sur La Table pans and picked Kana, about $23 for a 9-inch round. It’s one blogger’s four-pan test, and it’s the only side-by-side of its kind I found.
Best cake pans under $20
Good pans under $20 exist. These are the picks to look at:
- Chicago Metallic Commercial II 9-inch, $14.99. Reviewed’s best overall.
- Nordic Ware Naturals Nonstick 9-inch. ATK’s Best Buy, at about half its winner’s price.
- Wilton Perfect Results Nonstick 9-inch, about $16. ATK found the cake evenly baked, a bit darker, and slightly domed. Check price.
- Fat Daddio’s 9 x 2-inch, about $17. Uncoated, so line it.
Skip two. In Reviewed’s test, the Wilton aluminum 8-inch set ($15.97) stuck cakes even after greasing and left runny centers. Its Parrish 9 x 2 pan measured under 9 inches and baked lopsided cakes.
Cheap pans save money only if they release and bake evenly. A $15 pan that tears the bottom off your cake costs you the cake.
How to prep and care for a cake pan
The best cake pans last for years with a few habits.
- Prep traditional pans. Grease the bottom, press in a parchment circle, grease the parchment and sides, dust with flour, and knock out the excess. how to line a cake pan with parchment]
- Prep nonstick pans lightly. Grease and flour them. Read the care card first. Calphalon doesn’t recommend baking spray.
- Adjust for the pan. Lower the oven slightly for deep pans, and check dark pans early.
- Cool before unmolding. Wait 15 to 30 minutes, run a thin offset spatula around the edge, then flip the cake onto a rack.
- Wash by hand. Don’t put a hot nonstick pan into cold water. Use silicone or wood tools, since metal scratches coatings.
Best cake pans: a quick decision guide
The best cake pans match the cake you bake most. Use this order of decisions:
- Layer cakes: a light-colored 9-inch round, 2 inches deep, with straight sides. Goldtouch Pro wins ATK’s test, and Nordic Ware Naturals costs about half as much. Buy three.
- Tight budget: Chicago Metallic at $14.99. Check cakes early, since dark finishes can dome.
- You line pans and want no coating: Fat Daddio’s anodized aluminum, about $17.
- Cheesecake: the Hiware set at about $22. Put it on a sheet pan.
- Bundt: Nordic Ware Heritage at about $40, or Cuisinart at $16.95.
- Angel food: a tube pan with feet, ungreased.
- PFAS concerns: uncoated aluminum or a silicone-based coating like USA Pan’s. Read each maker’s coating statement and your state’s rules.
Before you pay, check three things on any pan: depth of 2 inches or more, finish color, and how you’ll wash it.
FAQ
Do you need to grease a nonstick cake pan?
Yes, lightly. Saveur’s method for nonstick pans is a thin coat of grease and a dusting of flour. Some makers rule out baking spray, so read the care card first.
Is an 8-inch or 9-inch pan better for layer cakes?
Neither wins outright. ATK says the same batter fills two 9-inch pans or three 8-inch pans. The 8-inch layers come out thinner and bake sooner, while 9-inch layers are thick enough to split into four.
Are dark or light cake pans better?
Light, for layer cakes. ATK slightly preferred light pans because they browned more slowly and gave more even color. Dark pans brown faster, so start checking a minute or two early.
Are silicone cake pans worth buying?
Rarely for layers. Saveur says silicone is safe to 428 degrees F but conducts heat poorly and is fiddly to unmold. Save it for small individual desserts.
Are nonstick cake pans safe?
Owning one is legal everywhere, and several states now restrict sales of PFAS-coated cookware. Coatings differ in chemistry, so read the maker’s statement and stay under its temperature limit. Replace pans that flake.
How many cake pans do I need?
Three 9-inch rounds, so every layer bakes at once. Add a 9 x 13-inch pan for sheet cakes and a springform for cheesecake. For a first set, the best cake pans are those three rounds. Bundt and tube pans are optional.



